CBI report 'fundamentally flawed' warns UNISON
UNISON, the UK’s largest union, said today that a Confederation of British
Industry (CBI) report, claiming that billions could be saved by privatising
public services, is ‘fundamentally flawed’.
The report is based on an
assumption that savings of 11% can be made through outsourcing or privatisation
– a figure that has been ‘plucked out of the air’ by the CBI. This assumption is
then extrapolated and applied to more than £200bn of public spending.
The 11% savings calculation does not take into account the often huge
knock-on costs associated with privatisation including procurement, tendering
and contract management. It also omits to mention the huge cost to the taxpayer
and local people when the private sector fails, or that some public bodies have
brought public services back in-house after contracts have failed.
The
report also flies in the face of public attitudes to privatisation. Recent
polling by ComRes for UNISON* reveals a lack of public trust in private
companies providing public services. The polling reveals a widespread awareness
amongst the public that private companies fail to deliver on their contractual
obligations and that privatisation leads to lower quality services.
Dave
Prentis, UNISON General Secretary, said:
“This report is fundamentally
flawed. Where is the proof that 11% savings can be achieved by privatising
public services? The CBI has plucked this figure from the air. All the evidence
shows that privatisation is a costly failure that the taxpayer can ill afford.
Only last week MPs felt it necessary to call for a blacklist of firms that have
failed to deliver on their contracts.
“Privatisation failures carry
heavy human costs – just ask an elderly resident of an ex-Southern Cross home.
And, as the G4S Olympic fiasco clearly shows, when the private sector fails, the
public sector has to pick up the pieces – including the cost.
“Turkey’s
don’t vote for Christmas, and the CBI is hardly going to call for less
businesses involvement in public services. But recent polling has revealed that
privatisation is deeply unpopular with the public. If the government pushes
through with the CBI’s vision it would face the wrath of voters at the ballot
box.”
UNISON is calling for an urgent inquiry into privatisation and
outsourcing, including the companies that provide public services, their
employment practices, the quality of services they provide, as well as the
profits they make at taxpayers’ expense.
*Recent ComRes polling for
UNISON* shows that
62% do not trust private companies to run public
services.
Only one in five (20%) believe that privatisation has led to
better quality services to the public, nearly three times as many (55%) believe
that public services are of worse quality under privatisation.
81%
believe that private companies either frequently or sometimes fail to meet their
contractual obligations.
Privatisation failures
The CBI report
features case studies including the company May Gurney that provides recycling
services in North Somerset, which it holds up as a success story. However, after
more than 7000 public complaints about the service, the company was recently
fined more than £61,000. The company is also reportedly facing severe financial
difficulties, with a recent 41% drop in its share price – leaving these vital
public services in jeopardy.
Only last week it was reported that Serco,
a private company running out of hours GP services in Cornwall, had given false
data to the NHS on 252 occasions. This followed an inquiry, after fears were
raised that the service was so understaffed, it was unsafe – concerns about the
service and the effect on the public remain.
Six patients at Lister
Hospital suffered irreversible sight loss after they received poor aftercare
when they were treated by a private company owned by construction firm
Carillion.
Despite failing to deliver on its Olympics contract, G4S boss
Nick Buckles has admitted that he expects to be paid its £57 million management
fee in full, despite the public sector – the army – stepping in to keep the
Olympics safe.
Care home company Southern Cross collapsed in June 2011,
leaving the company’s 31,000 vulnerable residents facing huge uncertainty. The
company had been operated by a private equity firm that made money from a
complicated sale and leaseback arrangement with its buildings.
In August
this year, some workers at private care home Winterbourne View received a prison
sentenced after they were caught on camera abusing vulnerable patients. The home
has since been closed down.
UNISON takes fairness fight to European Court
UNISON, the UK’s leading public sector trade union, today (20 September) took
its fight for fairness in the long-running Alemo-Herron & Ors v Parkwood
Leisure Ltd case, to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
UNISON
is arguing that 24 members transferred from the London Borough of Lewisham to
Parkwood Leisure have the right to continue to benefit from nationally agreed
pay and terms set by the local government pay negotiations.
The
Advocate-General's opinion in this 7-year long case is expected on 31 January
2013.
UNISON General Secretary Dave Prentis, said:
“We are taking
our fight for fairness all the way to Luxembourg because we believe that we have
a strong case. Under TUPE regulations, Parkwood employees transferred from the
London Borough of Lewisham should be entitled to nationally agreed pay rises.
“This is an important case that will have implications for the thousands
of workers that have been transferred out of the public sector or are set to be
transferred. This is especially important in the current climate.”
Beecroft lite
UNISON, the UK’s largest union, today warned that the ‘Beecroft lite’
proposals to slash employment rights will only fuel insecurity, making the UK’s
unemployment levels higher and the recession worse.
These plans will cut
unfair dismissal awards, deter people from taking claims against rogue
employers, and put pressure on people to sign settlement agreements, under which
people sign away their right to taking an unfair dismissal case at a later date.
Coupled with new fees for Employment Tribunals due next year they represent a
‘lite’ proposal of those originally proposed by venture capitalist Adrian
Beecroft in his report to Government.
Dave Prentis, UNISON general
secretary, said:
“These ‘Beecroft lite’ proposals are still a blatant
attack on workers’ rights. The UK already has some of the weakest labour laws in
Europe. Weighing the scales heavily in favour of bosses - who can hire and fire
at will - will only fuel insecurity, lengthening the dole queues and making the
UK’s damaging recession worse.
“UNISON will also be campaigning hard
against plans to amend the TUPE rules that protect workers’ rights when they are
transferred from one employer to another. We suspect that in the name of
simplification the Coalition really want to make it easier transfer public
services to the private sector, and spark a race to the bottom on pay, terms and
conditions.”
Notes to editors:
UNISON is backing a campaign
against these measures asking MPs to vote against Enterprise and Regulatory
Reform Bill – within which many of these rules will be legislated:http://www.unionstogether.org.uk/under-attack
UNISON’s evidence to the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill
consultation can be found here: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201213/cmpublic/enterprise/memo/err48.htm
31/08/2012
House price rise - UNISON response
UNISON, the UK’s largest union, is today calling on the government to start
an urgent programme of building affordable homes. A survey by the Nationwide
Building Society out today reveals that UK house prices have bucked the
recession to rise by 1.3%.
Increasing the UK’s housing stock would not
only ease pressure in the housing market, but would help turn the corner on the
economic downturn. Five million people – 2 million households – in the UK are
currently on housing waiting lists.
Dave Prentis, UNISON General
Secretary, said:
“The government needs to be bold to help our country
recover from the recession. Initiating a programme of building affordable
housing would stimulate growth and give thousands of low paid families the
chance of a decent home.
“But when the UK urgently needs affordable
housing, the government has cut funding for social housing by more than £4
billion. What it could and should be doing is making capital funding available
to housing associations and local authorities so more homes can be built as a
matter of urgency.
Audit Commission report peddling dangerous myth - UNISON
A report from the Audit Commission that suggests councils can save money on
care assessments by replacing qualified social workers with non-qualified staff
is peddling a dangerous myth which will damage care standards and lead to longer
term costs, UNISON warned today.
The report, which also promotes
‘reviewing’ of pay levels as a method of cutting council costs, says that the
biggest cost in providing social care assessments is paying professionally
qualified staff. UNISON says that reducing the use of these professionals is
tantamount to providing essential social care on the cheap.
Using
non-professional staff to carry out work for which they are not trained places
inappropriate pressure on them, and places the vulnerable people they care for
at inexcusable risk. The complexity of adult care needs is ever increasing –
dementia, drug addiction, mental health conditions, vulnerability to abuse and
knock-on effects on children and families – and all these need the highest
possible levels of skills and qualifications to get assessments and care plans
right first time.
Helga Pile, UNISON national officer for social care
said:
“This is something we’ve been long concerned about in adult social
work – providing social care on the cheap – and the Audit Commission’s report is
yet more evidence of a flippant approach to care standards when it comes to
vulnerable adults.
“The Government has said it values the
professionalism of social workers in adult care –so we hope they will move
quickly to challenge these dangerous myths.
“The recommendations in this
report are too simplistic. They diminish the work of both the
professionally-qualified social workers – of which there are already a shortage
– and the support workers and social care assistants, who play a vital role in
the care of vulnerable people and don’t want to be ‘social workers on the
cheap’.
“UNISON cannot support recommendations that put pressure on
staff to do a job for which they may not be properly trained, for no extra pay,
and place the vulnerable people being cared for at risk. Social workers need to
be leading this work alongside support workers but it is dangerous to think you
can just replace them. The long-term consequences would be more unmet need at
greater cost to crisis services and hospital admissions.”
In 2011 UNISON
conducted a survey into the exploitation of social work assistants and support
workers being used as social workers in an attempt to reduce costs. It found
that two thirds of respondents were regularly given work with vulnerable
children and adults that they don't feel qualified or experienced enough to do,
only 25% said there were clear boundaries between their roles and that of social
workers and 75% of support staff normally worked over and above their contracted
week.
The 2011 survey can be found here: http://www.unison.org.uk/acrobat/stepping_into_the_breach_report.pdf
Rise in youth unemployment is fuelling a lost generation
UNISON, the UK’s largest union, is calling on the Government to take urgent,
coordinated action to tackle the scandal of rising youth unemployment. “It is
disgrace” said the union that the number of young people not in education,
employment or training (NEET) in England rose by 100,000 in the second quarter
of the year.
Jon Richards, UNISON Head of Education said:
“It is
a disgrace that so many of our young people are not in education, employment or
training and this figure is rising. Youth unemployment should be one of the
Government’s top priorities, instead they are creating a lost
generation.
“The government is fuelling the problem and sacrificing young
people’s futures by withdrawing access to decent careers guidance and gambling
that schools will fill the gap, with no additional funding. Faced with a bleak
jobs market, young people need a highly skilled, professional careers service
now more than ever. But in many towns and cities across the country they will
now find closed doors where their careers office used to be.
“We are
urging the government to step up, provide sufficient resources, and help restore
the high quality careers services that young people need to give them hope for
the future.”
The union is warning that the number of NEETs is set to rise
further as school and college leavers struggle to join the jobs market. Youth
unemployment should be one of the government’s top priorities yet it’s response
so far has been piecemeal and inconsistent, with responsibilities split across
the Department of Education, BIS and DWP – and no-one with responsibility for
the big picture.
At present no agency tracks or has responsibility for
young people making the onwards transition from school. Compared to other
northern European countries, young people in the UK are largely left to navigate
the transition to work and responsible adulthood alone.
Across the
country a damaging postcode lottery is also developing. In Birmingham - a city
in the top 20 youth unemployment hotspots - the budget for careers services has
fallen from £11m to £3.8m since 2010. More than two-thirds of the staff have
lost their jobs and only one advice centre remains open. In six London boroughs
- Kingston, Merton, Sutton, Richmond, Croydon and Bromley - all the Connexions
offices have been closed. In Hull the staffing levels of careers advisers has
been reduced from 81 to 18.
Notes to Editors
1. The Education Act
2011 places a new statutory duty on schools to secure access to independent
careers guidance for all pupils in years 9 to 11 from September 2012. This
should include information on all the options available in 16-18 education and
training, including apprenticeships, and should be impartial and independent,
and this is defined as ‘provided by persons other than those employed at the
school’. In-house provision must be complemented by external support, which
includes face-to-face guidance but only for those whom schools alone decide need
it.
2. Local Authorities, due to financial pressures, made massive cuts
in careers services provision in both 2010/11 and 2011/12. Research in 2011 has
shown that by July 2011 about 4,000 staff had been made redundant already and a
further 4,000 were at risk over the next year. Advice centres and services have
closed. This happened before the new careers service had been designed and
before the implementation of the Education Act that transferred commissioning
responsibility from Local authorities to schools from September 2012. In many
cases this could contravene the current statutory minimum service levels
expected.
3. Tens of thousands of young people effectively have no access
to ‘face to face’ career guidance services and in some Local Authorities, no
service is being provided at all. Current 14 -19 year old pupils will be the
least informed about their future career options in a generation, at a time when
the Government has radically changed the education and training environment by;
abolishing the Education Maintenance Allowance and the Future Jobs Fund, raising
HE tuition fees, reducing the number of HE / FE places For parents of children
currently in Year 10 or Year 11:for the year 2011/12 career guidance services
will be a geographical lottery. In some areas young people leaving compulsory
education will have no access to independent, expert career guidance at all.
New UNISON research 'final nail in the coffin for regional pay'
New research commissioned by UNISON has found the government’s arguments for
regional pay in the public sector to be ‘deeply flawed’ and based on a false
premise.
The research, carried out by Incomes Data Services (IDS) on
behalf of the union, puts paid to the government’s central argument for local
and regional pay determination, the suggestion that national public sector pay
scales ‘crowd out’ employment and investment by the private sector.
UNISON assistant general secretary Karen Jennings will be writing to MPs
with a copy of the research setting out the arguments and urging them to show
their support for national pay bargaining in the public sector.
On the
report, UNISON assistant general secretary Karen Jennings said:
“This
comprehensive report confirms what UNISON have said all along; the government’s
‘crowding out’ theory is deeply flawed and has no basis in fact. Now that the
government’s premise on regional and local pay is shown to be false, we would
urge them to stop this blatant attempt to drive down wages, disguised as
encouraging growth.
“This research demonstrates that public sector
employment doesn’t crowd out private sector investment, rather it complements it
and supports the local population.
“It’s time for the government to stop
attacking our vital public services, and instead concentrate on programmes of
investment and job creation, not just in London and the South East, that will
put money in people’s pockets and generate real growth in our struggling
economy.”
The report, Crowding out: fact or fiction, makes five key
points:
1. Public and private sector employers are not competing for the
same workers
2. Crowding out theory cannot work when unemployment is
high
3. Private sector pay does not vary hugely across regions
4.
Private sector job creation and job losses appear to be completely unaffected by
public sector pay
5. Public sector employment isn’t crowding out; it
supports local population.
Energy price rise brings winter misery
UNISON, the UK’s largest union, has today condemned energy company SSE for
imposing a massive 9% price hike, warning that doing so just before winter will
plunge thousands of customers into fuel poverty.
Mike Jeram, UNISON Head
of Business and Environment, said: “SSE are really letting their customers down
by enforcing a price hike – three times the rate of inflation – just before
winter sets in.
“Public service workers – many of whom have not had pay
increases for nearly three years – may find that it is not just their pay that
is frozen when they are struggling to heat their homes as a result of these
outrageous increases.
“It is not just SSE – many energy companies are
putting their prices up, putting the health and wellbeing of the low paid,
pensioners and the vulnerable at risk. The Government needs to take urgent
action to tackle fuel poverty, and UNISON is calling for an emergency programme
of energy efficiency measures designed to cut bills, create jobs and help pull
families out of the grip of fuel poverty.”
Unemployment stats
UNISON is today warning that the toll of unemployment will rise after the
summer as the Olympic effect wears off and thousands of temporary jobs come to
an end.
Students due to get their A Level results tomorrow (15 Aug) –
will enter a bleak jobs market. The rising cost of further education has priced
many thousands of young people out of their dream of going to university or
further education.
The union is urging the government to ditch its failed
austerity policies and promote growth through investment in jobs and services,
with targeted help for young people.
Dave Prentis, UNISON general
secretary, said:
“This small fall is welcome, but there will be no
Olympics’ legacy in the jobs market. The end of thousands of temporary jobs will
see unemployment climbing after the summer. Students waiting for A Level results
this week face a bleak jobs future. They are set to join the dole queues in high
numbers as the hike in tuition fees has priced many thousands of young people
out of their dream of going to university or into further education.
“The
Tories need to inspire a generation by rebuilding our economy and safeguarding
the future. This must include targeted help for young people, as a part of a
wider programme of government-led job creation. The continued austerity agenda
is condemning our economy to the slow lane.”
Inflation bad news for struggling families - UNISON
UNISON general secretary Dave Prentis said:
“This is more bad news for
the many families across the UK who are struggling to make ends meet.
“For public service workers who have had their pay frozen for nearly
three years and for the millions of unemployed, any increase in inflation will
hit their family finances hard.
“With rail fares set to soar well above
inflation, UNISON is calling on the the government to think again. The Olympics
have given the country a real boost, it is time for the Government to give the
economy the boost it needs to build a more secure future.”
No hope of a mortgage for many thousands of public service workers
Hundreds of thousands of public service workers including nurses, paramedics,
care and social workers are being priced out of the housing market, despite low
interest rates, said UNISON, the UK’s largest union.
The union is warning
that although the latest figures show that repossessions are low, many workers
cannot afford the high cost of home ownership in the first place and are being
let down by a lack of available social housing for rent.
Simon Watson,
UNISON National Officer for said:
“The pay freeze means that many
thousands of public service workers are being frozen out of owning their own
homes. Many simply cannot afford the high cost of ownership and cannot get a
mortgage in the first place.
“The Government needs to take urgent action
to increase the number and range of affordable rented accommodation. While
repossessions may have fallen, we know from our members working in housing
associations up and down the county, that tenants are struggling to pay high
rents and are falling into arrears.
“The UK’s economy is only getting
weaker and the Government needs to kick- start the recovery by boosting new home
building.”
New pensions charges scandal looms
The TUC is today calling on the government to ban employers from
passing on the costs of taking advice from consultants on the implementation of
their new legal duty to automatically enrol staff in a pension to staff pension
pots.
The largest employers need to start enrolling staff from this autumn, with
other employers following in a phased programme finishing with the smallest
employers in 2016. Many employers are seeking help from outside consultants to
ensure that they are meeting their new pension duties.
Large employers appear to be absorbing the costs of outside help, but some
medium and small employers are planning to recoup the costs of outside
consultancy from pension contributions - an additional charge on top of those
already levied by pension providers.
This practice, known as consultancy charging in the pensions world, is legal
but in a letter to pensions minister Steve Webb the TUC is calling on him to use
his powers to cap charges in pension schemes to outlaw consultancy charging.
The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) recently confirmed the
compatibility of consultancy charging and automatic enrolment, following
confusing guidance issued by the Financial Services Authority (FSA).
The FSA had suggested that fees for advice taken out of pension contributions
could lead to employers failing to satisfy rules on minimum contribution rates.
Non compliance with these rules can lead to a series of fines from the Pensions
Regulator.
However, the DWP subsequently explained that this only applies where fees are
paid before contributions enter an individual's pension pot - and therefore
consultancy charging is lawful if fees are paid after contributions have entered
the pension scheme. Whether or not staff will appreciate this distinction is
highly debatable, says the TUC.
TUC General Secretary Brendan Barber said: 'It is completely wrong
that staff who pay in auto-enrolment pensions should have to meet the employer's
costs of making sure that they obey the law. This is a cost that should fall on
the business as a whole.
'Particularly in low-paid sectors where staff change job frequently, those
unlucky enough to work for employers using consultancy charging could find a big
chunk of their pension going to consultants, rather than to provide retirement
income.'
'Auto-enrolment is a huge advance and the TUC is a strong supporter, but we
worry that consultancy charging will sour its introduction. We applaud pension
schemes such as NEST who have said that they will not implement consultancy
charging.'
High profits levels add to fuel poverty misery
“Ofgem needs to show its teeth and stop fuel companies from making excessive
profits at the expense of their customers” said Mike Jeram, UNISON Head of
Business and Environment today (26 July).
The union is calling on the
Government to take urgent action to stem the growing number of families being
dragged into fuel poverty by the high cost of gas and electricity. It is urging
the Government to introduce more energy efficiency programmes to help bring down
the cost of fuel and provide help for the lowest paid to insulate their homes to
a higher standard.
Mike Jeram went on to say:
“British Gas seems
to have sidestepped austerity Britain and passed the pain of the double dip
recession onto their domestic customers.
“How can it be right that
families across the UK are suffering from pay freezes, job cuts and struggle to
pay their fuel bills, at the same time as the company is posting a 23% profit
hike?
“We need strong regulation and Government action to protect
families and pensioners from profiteering.”
UNISON survey highlights devastating impact of education cuts
Government education cuts are depriving many young people and adults of the
chance to contribute fully to society, UNISON has warned today.
A new
freedom of information survey, sent by UNISON to all of the 248 further
education colleges in England has revealed the devastating impact government
funding cuts are having on learners and staff, with the situation set only to
get worse.
The survey results demonstrate how the cuts are limiting
access to further education, through course closures, reductions in admissions
and job cuts.
More than 60% of respondents said they had closed courses
that ranged from Aerospace engineering and construction, through to a-levels and
part-time adult learning. Colleges gave funding cuts and changes to funding
eligibility rules as the main reasons for cutting courses.
In addition,
despite record youth unemployment figures, the survey also reveals a drop in
enrolment figures for this academic year – with nearly 70% of respondents
reporting a fall. This was blamed primarily on the loss of the education
maintenance allowance.
Jon Richards, UNISON national secretary for
education & children’s services said:
“In these tough times, the
need for education and training has never been greater, yet our survey has
highlighted the devastating impact government funding cuts are having on our
further education college staff and students.
“In the first year of this
Tory-led coalition government, we saw nearly 6,000 redundancies in colleges.
This – teamed with more than 60% of colleges cutting courses, and nearly 70%
reporting a fall in admissions in this last academic year – all paints a very
grim picture for our further education services.
“These cuts are
depriving too many young people of the chance to contribute to and take part in
society. We know that many employers are looking for the very skills that FE
colleges are able to provide. If the government does not stop this attack on
education services, then we are looking at losing a generation to hopelessness
and unemployment.”
University and College Union general secretary, Sally
Hunt, said:
“If this trend of cutting continues quality will inevitably
suffer. The further education sector simply cannot continue to be asked to do
more for less. Investment in our colleges is essential if we are to kick-start
growth in economy. At a time when other countries are investing in producing
more highly-skilled workers we cannot afford a repeat of these large-scale
course closures and redundancies.
“We are losing the very people we need
to up-skill our workforce and train the next generation. We fear the situation
could get worse with the introduction of loans for older learners and the
government must ensure that participation does not fall any
further.”
Shadow minister for further education Gordon Marsden
said:
“This survey provides detailed evidence of just how the Tory-led
Governments cuts in further education funding are blighting the life chances of
hundreds of thousands of young and adult learners. They are being prevented from
getting new skills and jobs to kick start our economy and with the government
now scrapping direct financial support for many adult learners in favour of a
debt producing loans system, many of them could drop out. That would make life
for colleges and those who work in them even tougher.”
UNISON warning over community safety as police numbers drop
UNISON, the UK’s largest union, is warning that Government plans to make
further drastic cuts to police staff, PCSO’s and officers numbers will have
dangerous consequences for community safety. The warning comes in the wake of
Home Office data released today showing that the number of police staff,
officers and PCSO’s have fallen dramatically, as the number of volunteers has
risen by more than 10%.
Hit with cuts totalling £2.4 billion by 2015,
forces across the country are expected to carry on shedding jobs. Services are
also being sold off to private companies – which the union is warning will only
make cuts worse. Private companies, responsible to their shareholders, will have
to take profits out of taxpayers’ funds and jobs will be an obvious target for
cuts.
HMIC has already warned that three forces may not be able to
provide an effective and efficient service in the future – UNISON is warning
that this will spread to other forces unless the government takes action to
protect police numbers.
Ben Priestley, UNISON national officer for police
and justice, said;
“The government is playing a dangerous game with
public safety. Relying on volunteers to keep vital police services running as
police staff, officers and PCSOs lose their jobs will not keep our communities
safe. And with 32,000 jobs set to go by 2015 in forces across England and Wales,
this situation will only get worse.
“The cuts run the risk of turning
the clock back on falling crime rates, which are down to the goodwill, hard work
and dedication of well trained police and staff. The government must ditch the
cuts, stop promoting damaging police privatisation, and take action to keep our
communities safe.”
The government does have other choices that it could
and should be making. Instead of drastic cuts, a pro-growth, anti-austerity
alternative would help maintain the vital services that help to keep our
communities safe. The Tory-led coalition should tackle the banks, and bonuses,
take action on tax avoidance and tax havens. Putting the breaks on public
spending cuts would help fuel the growth that our economy so desperately
needs.
Olympic brand is forcing public safety into second place – UNISON
Thousands of Trading Standards hours are being used up in protecting the
Olympic brand and corporate sponsors, instead of protecting the public, UNISON
warned today.
The UK’s largest union called the commitment ‘hard to
justify in the light of swingeing cuts to Trading Standard budgets’ and said it
could put the public at risk by preventing officers from carrying out their
usual duties. A national survey of Trading Standards staff carried out by UNISON
raised these concerns, with 40% of respondents saying the London 2012 Olympics
would have a ‘major impact’ on the workload of their local Trading Standards
services.
Trading Standards carry out a wide range of work, including
tackling loan sharks, reducing doorstep crime, seizing unsafe children’s toys
and stopping underage tobacco sales. In spite of this, Trading Standards budgets
are facing enormous cuts: In the 24 months between 2010/11 and 2012/13 Trading
Standards budgets in England have fallen by more than £28.6m amounting to a 16%
cut.
Helga Pile, UNISON national officer, said:
“Consumers rely
on the hard work of trading standards officers in so many ways from identifying
dangerous goods to tackling rogue traders. With fewer officers left in the
service, those that remain are going the extra mile to deal with the upsurge in
counterfeit goods, ticket touting and illegal street trading that the Olympics
will inevitably bring. But diverting so much resource to protecting the Olympic
brand – and the financial interests of huge corporations such as McDonalds and
Coca-Cola – is hard to justify when budgets have been squeezed so
hard.
“Trading Standards officers want to do their bit for the Olympics
but they also have to make sure the public is protected from real threats and
that leads to questions about whether the brands should be the priority.
“Once the Olympics is over it is the hard-stretched Trading Standards
officers that will have to pick up the backlog as well as the pieces when things
go wrong.”
Thirty local authorities are directly involved with
protecting the Olympic enforcement, and the staff contribution amounts to the
equivalent of 342 enforcement days. The cost is being estimated at £868,000 -
the ODA is paying local authorities the hourly rate for the officer time. Other
local authorities are also affected in providing cover and prioritising brand
protection.
Respondents to the UNISON survey highlighted the impact this
commitment is having on carrying out their duties. One said: “Brand protection
for London 2012 appears to be the priority which is being imposed on our service
from above. The driver is protecting trademark holders, not protecting the
public from counterfeit goods.”
Another said: “Officers [are being]
seconded to work as enforcement officers for the ODA. The rest of the department
has been told that brand protection (normally a very light touch area of
enforcement) will take higher priority”
Respondents spoke of the impact
on other work: “Other important areas of work will have to be put back or missed
out entirely die to coverage for the London Olympics”
UNISON responds to IMF budget warning
UNISON is urging the government to heed and act upon the IMF report telling
the government it will have to slow the pace of cuts if it does not see growth
return before the end of this year.
UNISON general secretary Dave
Prentis said:
“This is a damning verdict from the IMF, and one which the
government would be foolish to ignore. However, there is no point in waiting
until the end of the year before calling a halt to these damaging cuts and
injecting some growth into the economy.
“For more than two years we’ve
warned this government against their austerity agenda, and for more than two
years they have ploughed ahead with vicious attacks on our public services, and
made life that bit harder for thousands of people across the UK.
“The UK
cannot continue like this, and decisive action to encourage growth must be
taken, and taken now, to prevent even more damage being done.”
12-week consultation period should stay as minimum
UNISON, the UK’s largest union, today called on the Government to keep the
12-week consultation period as the minimum needed to avoid hasty, ill-thought
through decision making.
The union supports a more flexible timescale to
allow for a longer upper limit for complex policy making decisions, but said the
12-week period should stay as a minimum.
Karen Jennings, UNISON Assistant
General Secretary, said:
“Cutting the 12 week consultation period will
allow ill-though through policy making decisions to come onto the statute book,
which is then a nightmare to unravel. It is vital that all parties affected by
policy changes have sufficient time to consider the implications of changes and
12 weeks should be the minimum.
“It is ironic that the Government failed
to consult on this change, opting instead to get feedback on how it should be
implemented, not if it should be implemented at all.”
Court of appeal gives stabbed social worker right to sue health authorities
A social worker stabbed by a psychiatric patient for whose child she was
responsible, has today won her case at the Court of Appeal giving her the right
to sue two health authorities responsible for her attacker’s care.
UNISON
member Claire Selwood was stabbed six times by Graham Burton, of Murton, after
he confronted her during a professional conference at his child’s school in
County Durham. Just two days earlier he had told medical staff at Cherry Knowle
Hospital, Sunderland that he would kill her on the spot if he saw her. This was
the last of a number of threats that were not acted upon.
Her attacker
left the 42-year-old mother of three for dead. She suffered life- threatening
injuries and was profoundly traumatised by her ordeal.
If the case is
ultimately successful, it could result in every NHS Trust and local authority
being required to check that threats against the personal safety of social
workers and other vulnerable lone workers are made known to all parties, taken
seriously and acted on, says trade union UNISON.
Gill Hale, UNISON
Northern Regional Secretary, said:
“The attack on Claire was shocking,
but also shocking is the fact that it could and should have been prevented.
Threats had been made by Burton on several occasions but Ms Selwood was never
warned that her life might be in danger. We welcome today’s decision, which
could lead improved safety for lone workers like Claire.
“Organisations
such as local authorities and NHS Trusts must protect vulnerable workers in the
workplace. There must be procedures when threats are made against staff that
work for or with them.
“Organisations working in partnership with social
workers and other vulnerable workers must be required to do a ‘Selwood Check’ to
make sure that any threats made to employee’s lives are taken seriously and
acted on.
“We will continue to support Claire in her fight for justice
and demand that measures be put in place to avoid this type of preventable,
disturbing attack happening again.”
Claire Selwood said:
“This has
been a difficult time and I am very grateful for the help and assistance I have
received from UNISON.”
Following the attack UNISON took up her case and
began a claim for compensation against Ms Selwood’s employer Durham County
Council, and the Tees Esk and Wear Valley NHS Trust and Northumberland Tyne and
Wear NHS Foundation Trust.
The case against the two NHS Trusts was
dismissed by Newcastle County Court on the grounds they did not owe Ms Selwood a
duty of care, but she was given leave to appeal.
Today, Wednesday 18
July, the Court of Appeal accepted it was arguable the two NHS Trusts did owe
her a duty of care based on their responsibilities under an agreed protocol. Ms
Selwood can now continue the claim against her employer and the NHS
Trusts.
If the case is ultimately successful, it would reinforce the need
for every NHS Trust and other relevant authorities to fulfil their obligations
under the ‘working together’ protocol.
Following the attack UNISON
instructed legal experts Thompsons Solicitors to advise Ms Selwood.
Mick
Laffey from Thompsons said:
“The Court of Appeal decision highlights the
importance of social services and NHS Trusts communicating with each other to
protect the lives of vulnerable workers. It is not good enough to pay lip
service to health and safety.”
Burton was jailed indefinitely in June
2007 for the attempted murder of Ms Selwood. An independent inquiry found a
‘complete failure’ by medical staff to warn her of any danger.
Olympic effect will not last warns UNISON
Commenting on the job loss figures that show unemployment has fallen,
UNISON General Secretary, Dave Prentis, said:
“Sadly the unemployed
cannot and the government should not take comfort from these figures. The
Olympic effect may give the impression of a recovery, but it is a mirage. The
number of long-term unemployed is still rising, and huge numbers of women and
young people are still struggling to find work.
“Under the coalition’s
no-hope economic plan, hundreds of thousands more public sector jobs are due to
be axed. There is no demand in our economy to fuel growth - consumer confidence
is low, and people do not have enough cash to spend in their local shops and
businesses. The government has to take evasive action. We need an alternative
plan for sustainable jobs and economic growth, to put the country back on the
road to recovery.”